Clumsy, hollow prequel makes for summer’s first train wreck.
Neither a fresh reimagining of the stagnant X-Men film franchise or a back to basics return to what made Bryan Singer’s first two efforts in the series often (if never completely) enthralling, director Matthew Vaughn’s X-Men: First Class struggles to find its narrative footing and then collapses beneath a Frankenstein script and leaden, arrythmic pacing. Squandering an intriguing retro setting and a premise that ought to write itself on derivative and pained action sequences and mawkish dramatics, the film amounts to a long, tired rehash of a lot of hoary marketing gimmicks. And amid a widely divergent field of performances it includes an aggressively terrible performance by a veteran character actor who ought to know better.
The film starts with a scene lifted verbatim from Singer’s vastly superior X2, detailing Erik Lensherr’s - the boy who will grow up to become Magneto – struggles in a Polish concentration camp during World War II. This film continues his ordeal under scientist/cackling maniac Sebastian Shaw (Kevin Bacon), whose sadistic methods kickstart the young mutant’s abilities. Meanwhile in England, a young Charles Xavier befriends homeless, shape-shifting waif Raven, promising her a safe haven despite her otherwordly appearance.
Jump ahead to the early 1960s, when Shaw is under investigation by the CIA for interfering with U.S. military operations. Agent Moira McTaggert (Rose Byrne) infiltrates his casino/brothel and witnesses the mutant powers of several of his henchmen, but is dismissed by stodgy superiors who use her findings as evidence women shouldn’t be operatives. Instead, she contacts Oxford University grad Xavier for insight into mutations. Though the young geneticist’s earnest briefing is likewise met with skepticism, he and Raven are recruited by an agency scientist (Oliver Platt) to head up a division of mutant spies.
An aborted attempt to catch Shaw brings Xavier into contact with Lensherr, who’s spent his adult life stalking his former tormentor around the world in search of vengeance. Lensherr reluctantly joins the fledgling group, accompanying Xavier on a recruitment drive around the country. The script uses a familiar structure for this, one for which TV Tropes.org has a pretty ironic name, and it allows for a surprise cameo given extra spice by the precise use of an f-bomb.
The new recruits, who include a cab driver named Darwin (Edi Gathegi) who can adapt instantly for any situation and a stripper with dragonfly wings (Zoe Kravitz), continue their training until Shaw orders an attack on their compound. The resulting combat under Vaughn’s orchestration becomes both belabored and mean-spiririted, with repeated and derivative violence that fails to establish the bad guy’s menace so much as their one-dimensionality. One of Xavier’s team is murdered, and another defects, in efforts the script ostensibly intends to bring context to the Xavier-Magneto struggles of the later films. In fact it returns to that ambition time and again (at 132 minutes long, it’s got plenty of time) but seldom completely pulls it off.
Because Xavier, Lensherr, and Raven (played in adulthood by Jennifer Lawrence) are the only fully developed characters the script allows, the rest of the “first class” are practically cyphers, distinguishable solely by their powers or, more cynically, their boy band-esque personality types: the bad boy (Lucas Till), the sensitive one (Caleb Landry Jones) the geeky one (Nicholas Holt). Their training, free of the government’s meddling – us kids can do it for ourselves! – goes off with little impediment or setback, save the semi-humorous kind typical of such sequences. The evil mutants working for Shaw – teleporting Darth Maul knockoff Azazel (Jason Flemyng) and Euro-chic tornado thrower Riptide (Alex Gonzalez) – are similarly underdeveloped.
Shaw’s master plan sets the stage for the Cuban Missile Crisis, which Xavier, Lensherr and the gang scramble to stop. The ensuing set piece makes for the film’s best sequence, allowing all the mutants to finally let loose with their powers. Though too much of the sequence details the U.S. and soviet navies looking on in fear and hostility, until its conclusion the battle is well-orchestrated and even suspenseful, a welcome relief after the previous plodding 90 or so minutes. Having said that, plot holes and continuity errors trouble its narrative coherence all the while.
When the battle’s over and the character interaction resumes, the film again finds itself in trouble. The reasons for Xavier’s confinement to a wheelchair are revealed with the grace of a sledgehammer, and with a bathos that defies common sense. Lensherr’s character arc ultimately lands him on the side of the devils, as we knew it would, and in joining him Raven becomes the terrorist Mystique (Rebecca Romihn puts in a cameo as her grown up self, too.) The film can’t resist indulging in multiple denouement, letting Xavier and Lensherr both come to their epiphanies about their identities.
Fassbender is compelling and charming as the haunted Lensherr, and Lawrence is affecting as the shape-changer with no sense of herself. The worst turn, ironically, belongs to the film’s most seasoned veteran. Bacon is hammy and nonchalant playing a villain who ought to be halfway between Dr. No and Dr. Mengele, and his nonchalance works against the film’s sum dramatic weight. In terms of performance his idea of evil apparently runs more to Gene Hackman’s Lex Luthor than Heath Ledger’s Joker, in a way that sometimes patronizing; at other times the apathy seems to waft off him. Another weak turn comes from January Jones, playing Shaw’s operative/concubine Emma Frost. Perhaps because of the 60′s setting she recycles her Betty Draper iciness, but only to diminishing returns.
The film’s screenplay carries no less than six writing credits, including Singer and Vaughn both, and the confusion typical of too many cooks in the storytelling kitchen create persistent, debilitating troubles that the final film product never takes time to figure out. At the risk of second-guessing, it’s sometimes tempting to try to spot the segments that must have come from the aborted Magneto-only prequel rumored several years ago, and then to call out the parts that must have accumulated with successive treatments – the toyetic Azazel, the tween-friendly Xavier recruits, the cursory understanding of Cold War geopolitics. All in the name of money, of course, and served up with enough bombast that maybe you won’t notice. X-Men: First Class is a film that doesn’t expect very much from itself. It hopes you won’t either.
- Michael Kabel







































The 81st annual Academy Awards takes place this Sunday, oddly coming just after the movie industry’s biggest January to date. The ceremony is hosted by Hugh Jackman, who when considering some previous hosts (Billy Crystal, David Letterman, Bob Hope) is if nothing else probably the best-looking emcee since Douglas Fairbanks had the honor back in 1929.
Actress In A Supporting Role: Should win: Viola Davis, Doubt. Will win: Amy Adams, Doubt. Adams is a rising star with a previous nomination and leading lady good looks – a winner the Academy can feel good about coronating. Davis (Nights in Rodanthe) is a veteran character actress who disappears into parts, especially in the Steven Soderbergh films Out of Sight and Solaris. Adams gives a fine performance, but Davis shines in her too-brief screen time. Dark horse: Marisa Tomei, The Wrestler. Tomei might pick up the award if enough voters want to bury the urban legend that she didn’t truly win for My Cousin Vinny.
Actress In A Lead Role: Should win: Melissa Leo, Frozen River. Will win: Kate Winslet, The Reader. Leo’s turn in the downer Frozen River brought her the attention she’s deserved at least since 21 Grams six years ago. All the same, The Reader marks Winslet’s sixth nomination without a win, and her turn as a Nazi cougar is the kind of showpiece performance that wins awards. Dark horse: Meryl Streep, Doubt. We imagine by now Streep’s name appears on the Academy’s ballot template.
Writer (Adapted Screenplay): Should win: Peter Morgan, Frost/Nixon. Will win: David Hare, The Reader. Morgan adapted his own play to the screen without losing intensity or focus, but veteran playwright Hare (The Hours, Damage) and The Reader have the pedigrees and controversy. Dark horse: Eric Roth and Robin Swicord, The Curious Case of Benjamin Button. Roth and Swicord built a lot off of F. Scott Fitzgerald’s short story, even if most of it wasn’t particularly well-developed. Still, the Academy loves a romantic epic.
Directing: Should win: Of the nominees, Danny Boyle, Slumdog Millionaire. Will win: Danny Boyle, Slumdog Millionaire. Boyle’s film is conspicuously absent in the acting categories, and giving him the statue for his long career of work will offset the sting if voters opt not to give the mixed-reviewed Slumdog the Best Picture statue. Dark horse: Neglecting to recognize Nolan for The Dark Knight was a bit of stodginess that the Academy will likely regret in years to come. It’s a virtually flawless work that transcends its genre basis without compromising any of its elements.
As discussed in numerous media outlets (including
But ironically the nuance of Rourke’s performance stands in stark contrast to the merciless heavy-handedness of Siegel and Aronofsky. Like the rabid fans roaring and chanting with Randy’s every move, the film’s creators seem to take perverse pleasure in watching the Randy endure pain – not from the barbed wire and staple guns strewn about the wrestling ring, but rather from a gauntlet of rejection and disappointment relentlessly pummeled upon him. This string of pathos-inducing defeats provides fertile ground for Rourke the actor to prove that he’s still got it, but for the audience such an exhibition of brutality isn’t revelatory so much as it becomes tedious and tiresome.
It’s therefore no surprise that any attempts at symbolism or metaphor are patronizing and paper-thin, perhaps best evidenced by an early scene in which Pam compares Randy the Ram to Jesus Christ. Similarly, Randy can’t build relationships with the two women in his life, so he returns to the glory and camaraderie of the wrestling ring where he (presumably) dies of a heart attack. He dies of a broken heart, you see? Ugh. Making matters worse, Aronofsky’s choppy editing and awkward transitions only heighten the narrative disconnect. Subtlety has never been his strong suit, and unfortunately here he returns to the tawdry heavy-handedness that permeated 2000′s epically overrated Requiem For A Dream. Aronofsky’s fixation with employing shock value for its own sake is most apparent in a graphic tryst between Randy and a fetishist barfly, a scene that’s so clumsily handled it plays as film school amateurish.
As for the supporting cast, Wood perhaps best exemplifies the inelegance of Aronofsky’s approach to his cast: her eyes, face and voice all convey the intensity of her character’s heartache even as her hands slash the air in a series of awkward gesticulations. The actress obviously possesses the talent and the chops for her difficult role, but she’s sorely in need of, well, direction. That makes Aronofsky’s obvious disinterest in developing her character all the more disappointing.
Christian Bale has built a career of taking roles that would scare off most actors and break other, less intrepid leading men in half. Even momentarily ignoring (if such a thing is still possible) his three most famous films – the two Batmans and his turn as serial killer Patrick Bateman in American Psycho- his resume reveals a variety of parts in a swath of films that are connected only by what they’re not: they’re not crowd pleasers. No romantic comedies, no sweeping historical romances, nothing that lets him play to the Oscar highlight reel or get his face on the cover of slick magazines. He’s an actor that acts.
2005′s Harsh Times, written and directed by James Avery (Training Day, Street Kings) casts Bale as Jim Luther Davis, a not-especially-bright Army Ranger returned to his bowels-of-L.A. home turf after years of service in Afghanistan. Davis has two humble goals for the rest of his life: to marry his impoverished Mexican sweetheart and bring her to the states; and to join either the LAPD or “the feds” so as to better enhance his standing among the lower echelons of the city’s crime community.
Avery’s directorial debut shows his Scorcese-like ambitions still just outside his grasp – it’s not unfair to call the film Mean Streets of L.A. – but he’s adept at making the city shift and groan with texture and nuance. Bale wanders through its environs slightly nervous and a little annoyed at the same time, as if the place itself was too different and too intimidating to reconcile with his expectations.
The prospect of Bale at odds with Hugh Jackman – Batman versus Wolverine! – as Victorian Era magicians in an escalating game of oneupsmanship must have brought thousands of comics fans to see 2006′s The Prestige, based on a novel by British writer Christopher Priest and directed by Batman auteur Christopher Nolan. Rival illusionists once apprenticed to the same master, (Ricky Jay, whose very appearance virtually counts as a pedigree) the two men are disciplined, obsessive, and driven in their quest to outdo one another after a tragedy drives them apart. Nolan frames the movie as a magic trick itself; it’s the kind of film that some guess its big twist halfway through while others need its shell game explained to them in the lobby afterwards.
Bale plays his Alfred Borden as a well of cold fury and restraint, never letting the audience see him moving things “behind the scenes” in his mind. Jackman is warm, charming and personable, qualities that themselves may be an illusion. Michael Caine brings his usual effortlessness to the role of magician’s valet; Scarlett Johansson, David Bowie, Andy Serkis and Roger Rees also appear as men and women caught in the two men’s colliding orbits. Bowie especially is a weird but apt choice to play the mad inventor Tesla, a man worthy of a big-budget biography if ever one lived.
If Bale’s Borden is a character with everything inside, conversely the role of Dieter Dengler in Warner Herzog’s 2006 Rescue Dawn demanded that everything be played on the outside. Or rather, what little of Bale remained after losing fifty-five pounds to play the part of a Navy pilot shot down over Laos in 1965. Written and directed by Werner Herzog and loosely based on events covered in his own 1997 documentary Little Dieter Needs To Fly, the film focuses not on the deprivations that Dengler and the other prisoners receive but instead on the physical and emotional toll their imprisonment inflicted.










