A focus on action works for and against the Green Goliath’s return to the screen.
It’s possibly a milestone of sorts – a small, dubious one – that the superhero film canon is now large enough that we have precedents for some comic book properties making their way back and forth between comics and theatres. The Incredible Hulk, the latest and once-again Marvel Comics hero to make the leap, is a re-imagining of the same characters that populated Ang Lee’s little-loved 2003 “thinking person’s action film” Hulk. Five years can be a long while in Hollywood, and this time director Louis Leterrier (The Transporter) emphasizes amazement rather than thought-provocation. That creates a different kind of film, but not necessarily an altogether successful one, either.
Lee’s film is acknowledged briefly, elliptically, as a kind of opening credits prologue and then dropped altogether. Dr. Bruce Banner (Edward Norton), the Hulk’s human alter-ego, has fled to a nondescript existence in Brazil, working at a soda bottling plant and practicing martial arts to help control his anger. But when a small accident inadvertently alerts the domineering Army General “Thunderbolt” Ross (William Hurt) to his whereabouts, Banner must flee a team of commandos led by snarling black-ops expert Emil Blonsky (Tim Roth) and head back to the States. There he’s reunited with his true love Betty Ross (Liv Tyler), the general’s daughter, and seeks the assistance of scientist Internet buddy Dr. Samuel Sterns (Tim Blake Nelson) in finding a cure.
Events come to a head in New York – where there’s plenty of stuff for Hulk to smash – after Blonsky takes a derivative of a long buried super-soldier serum as well as receives a transfusion of Banner’s blood. The two treatments combined warp him into, as Sterns explains in typical Marvel comics hyperbole, “an abomination!” And in the kind of chain of events of which three-act action movie screenplays are made, Banner must unleash his Hulk persona to stop Blonsky from killing Betty and her father. In fact Zak Penn’s script hits all the right tones on time, creating a well-plotted, easy to follow, and approachable summer movie to bring the kids to or just to give the brain a siesta.
But for a movie built on action, the action sequences themselves are less than breathtaking. Leterrier wants to build thrills around prolonged set pieces as he has in his other works, but there’s a difference in suspense watching Jason Statham attempt to jump between roofs and watching a 20-foot tall green CGI effect accomplish the same feat (though to be fair, the CGI is all top-notch, especially the Hulk himself). While a subsequent battle on a college campus is gripping for its use of military overkill, the initial firefight and ensuing chase sequence in Brazil has a loose, drawn-out quality that never feels compelling.
The final Hulk-Abomination smackdown should play like a literal clash of the titans, but comes across as no more visceral than combatants in any of a hundred fighting video games. It doesn’t help that aside from the defeat of the marginally sociopathic Blonsky and the salvation of Betty (her jeopardy depicted in rote perfunctory closeups), there’s little at stake to make the battle royale meaningful. Lee’s version, ironically, was drenched in its humanity to a fault, but this film goes too far the other way.
Norton delivers as the tormented Banner, finding the slight scientist’s heroism in never succumbing to self-terror or allowing himself a moment’s indulgence. Tyler, playing a cellular biologist, isn’t that far removed from her performance as Arwen in The Lord of the Rings trilogy – another lovestruck daughter of a hardass military leader. Hurt’s lines are delivered with a dialtone in front, though Nelson plays Dr. Sterns with the same pop-eyed energy he brought to the role of Delmar in O Brother, Where Art Thou? Only Roth falls flat as Blonsky, giving another in a line of tedious bad guy performances that neither reveals the root of his character’s evil nor hints at the ultimate extent of same.
Finally, there’s a tradition in Marvel films of paying homage to previous versions of the character portrayed in subtle allusions and references. It’s a sweet counterpoint to the sturm and drang of the films’ other elements, and here they’re especially welcome. Lou Ferrigno of the 70s television series has a short role as a security guard, while his co-star the late Bill Bixby is ingeniously shown on a Portugese-language episode of The Courtshp of Eddie’s Father. Even the show’s haunting theme music is briefly used. But to make a small gripe, amid such tribute the inclusion of Stan Lee’s inevitable cameo feels forced and egregious. Lee has perhaps received recognition enough for his work buidling the Marvel pantheon, and it’s time to give his frequent (and dearly missed) collaborator Jack Kirby his just props, as well.
- Michael Kabel
::
::
::
::
::
::
::
::
::
::
::